Opens in a new tab
Insights

How many COPs does it take to change a lightbulb?

Four floods in a month

Imagine you live in a kampung house near the river. Your household earns less than the poverty line, from casual work that pays by the day. Floods come most years, and you have learnt to store your belongings on higher ground.

This time the water keeps rising. You spend a week in a relief centre with thousands of your neighbours. When you return, the mattresses, the fridge you are still paying off, the motorcycle you ride to work, the children’s school uniforms and books, and the folder with your identity cards are gone. Like most Malaysian homeowners, you have no flood insurance. With no payout coming, you borrow from relatives to put the house back together, while losing pay for the days you cannot work. You start again a few rungs lower than before.

This scenario is real for many households on the East Coast, including Pasir Mas in Kelantan which recorded the most evacuees in the November 2024 floods. Recently, on the other side of the peninsula, floodwater rose to waist height along several lanes of Kampung Melayu Subang (Bernama). It was the area’s fourth flash flood in about a month. Nearly 550 homes and more than 1,000 residents had been affected (Malaysiakini). 

This week, nearly 200 governments, including Malaysia, are meeting in Antalya for COP31, the 31st round of UN climate talks. The Paris Agreement, adopted at COP21 in 2015, promised to limit warming and help the most vulnerable adapt. Eleven years on, households like this one are still waiting for change. 

The climate cost of being poor

Being poor is expensive. Lower-income households pay more in money, time, health and lost opportunity. Housing costs push them geographically further from work, so they spend more on transport and more hours getting there. That is time they cannot spend earning, studying or resting.

Climate change adds a second layer to the same bill. The poorest homes sit closest to rivers and in the lowest-lying land, where land is cheapest (Winsemius et al., 2018). They hold their wealth in physical assets such as furniture, vehicles and appliances, which is exposed to flood risk. Few Malaysian households carry flood insurance: 74% of homeowners had none in 2021 (Zurich Malaysia). After a flood, they face stagnant water, mosquitoes and disease, often with less access to quality healthcare.

A wealthier household suffers a loss, but a poorer one is pushed into a lower income bracket for years, entrenching them in a vicious socio-economic cycle. 

What the numbers hide

Malaysia counts its flood losses carefully, in ringgit of assets lost. Those figures say little about what a flood costs a household. The Department of Statistics Malaysia (DOSM) puts 2021 flood losses at RM6.1 billion, with about half in Selangor, one of the country’s wealthiest states (Malay Mail, citing DOSM). In 2022 the pattern flipped: Terengganu, Kelantan and Pahang took over 82% of RM622.4 million in losses (Malay Mail, citing DOSM).

Absolute losses are tied to assets, so rich states post the biggest numbers. The actual burden follows income. A RM20,000 loss is an inconvenience in one household and a lost decade of savings in another. Kelantan shows what that looks like. It had the lowest median household income of any state in 2022, at RM3,614 a month (Malay Mail, citing DOSM), and the second-highest poverty rate in 2024, at 11.5% (DOSM). In the November 2024 floods, Pasir Mas recorded more evacuees than any other district, nearly 25,000 at the peak (Bernama). That year Kelantan also suffered the heaviest losses to homes of any state, at RM139 million (Human Resources Online, citing DOSM).

The global evidence points the same way. A 2024 study by Gilli and colleagues estimates that climate damage within countries is regressive: poorer households lose a larger share of income than richer ones, even after allowing for a country’s ability to adapt. Under roughly 3.6°C of warming with no further action, they find inequality, measured by the GINI index, could rise by up to six points in the hardest-hit regions, notably Sub-Saharan Africa (Gilli et al., 2024, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management).

In other words, unchecked climate change shrinks the economy and widens the gap between those who can absorb the damage and those who cannot.

Where COP stands

The COP process does have a tool for exactly this problem: the Fund for responding to Loss and Damage, agreed at COP27 and operationalised at COP28. Its job is to help vulnerable developing countries recover from climate disasters. Three years on, pledges total US$822 million, and only about US$449 million has actually been paid in (ActionAid USA, April 2026).

Demand has already outrun supply. A UN report released as COP31 opened found the Fund’s first funding round drew US$2.8 billion in requests against US$342 million available (To Vima, citing UN findings). The same report found that even if adaptation finance triples by 2035, as agreed at COP30, it would cover only 20–29% of estimated needs. On the opening day, a bid to put tripling adaptation finance on COP31’s agenda as its own item failed to win consensus.

Size is one gap. Measurement is another. COP measures progress in tonnes avoided and dollars pledged. It rarely asks whether money reaches the household on the riverbank, or how much of a family’s wealth a disaster erased. A fund that pays governments months after the water recedes cannot help a family that needs to replace a fridge this week.

Measure who pays

Malaysia has a ready vehicle for this. The Malaysia National Adaptation Plan (MyNAP), funded by a EUR 2.8 million Green Climate Fund grant, has been in development since early 2025 (MGTC). Its framework already recognises that socio-economic status shapes vulnerability (NAP Global Network). But the plan has missed its earlier 2026 targets, and in October the minister gave no new deadline (The Edge Malaysia). When MyNAP lands, its test should be simple: does it measure losses by household income, and does its money reach the households that lose the most?

What gets measured gets delivered. If we want climate policy to protect the people most exposed, we have to start counting their losses by the burden those losses place on a household.

  1. Count the burden on households. DOSM already publishes flood losses by state and district. Adding losses by household income group, and as a share of household income, would show policymakers where a ringgit of protection does the most good.
  2. Close the gap between the quick fix and the permanent fix. Selangor will raise the Sungai Pelempas bund by up to a metre at a cost of under RM1 million, while the larger flood mitigation plan for the area may take four to five years (The Star). Households need protection, cash support and affordable cover in the years before the permanent works are finished.
  3. Hold international finance to a household test. Loss and damage money and adaptation finance should report how much reaches communities directly, how fast, and whether it arrives as grants or as debt.

None of this needs a new treaty. It needs the people who design and deliver policy to treat distribution as a result they track and report.

Five questions to ask as COP31 closes

The talks in Antalya end on 20 November. When the final negotiations land, these questions will tell you whether they bring changes to households like Pasir Mas:

  • Does the outcome mention inequality within countries, or only between them?
  • Is there new money for the Loss and Damage Fund, and how much is paid in rather than pledged?
  • Can communities and local governments reach that money directly, or only national treasuries?
  • Does adaptation finance arrive as grants, or as loans that add to the debts of poorer countries?
  • Do the indicators for tracking adaptation measure people protected and incomes preserved, or only projects funded?

If the answers are mostly no, perhaps it is going to take several more COPs to change a lightbulb.

Author:

Wan Hidayat Sallehudin
Senior Associate

——- 

Let’s transform together. Contact us at: https://pemandu.org/contact-us/

Related Articles

Our commitment to collaboration fosters

Strategic alliances with
Cordence Worldwide

— empowering us to achieve more side by side.
Learn More
Perintis Akal is a proud partner of

Our network of
transformational leaders

— reforming industries and shaping the future together.
Learn More
Our passion for excellence has earned us

Recognition, Awards,
and Achievements

— but it's the impact we create that truly drives us.